Housing crisis may prompt another tent city
Ian Stewart/Yukon News

Nancy Tanner is the manager of the Beez Kneez Bakpakers hostel in downtown Whitehorse. "If Whitehorse is going to grow and start bringing in workers, then it's got to find more housing," said Tanner.
In the last 12 months, Nancy Tanner has helped more than 100 people find housing in Whitehorse.
But it’s not her job.
“I see it as my unofficial duty,” said the manager of the Beez Kneez Bakpackers hostel in downtown Whitehorse.
Tanner has been managing the hostel for four years and in that time she’s seen the housing situation go from “bad to worse to horrible.”
On Tuesday three of Tanner’s guests were sitting in the common room trolling the Internet.
All of them were looking for places to live.
James had moved to Whitehorse from Vancouver after landing a job with the Yukon government.
“There was a buzz about Whitehorse and I was looking for a different lifestyle,” he said.
But so far, he hasn’t been able to find a place to live.
In Vancouver it’s a tenant’s market, he said. “But up here any housing ads are gone in five seconds.
“I don’t know anybody yet, but you seem to need to know someone to get a place.”
Robert Becher is having the same problem.
The pilot moved north for work and wasn’t too worried about finding a place.
“Before moving up, I was looking online at Kijiji and there were lots of ads for places,” said Becher.
“But once I got up here they were all rented out.”
If it comes down to it, he said he’s “always got a truck and can sleep in that.”
When Tanner started at Beez Kneez, she’d help guests comb the local newspapers for rental options.
“But people stopped putting ads in the paper about a year and a half ago,” she said. “Because they were getting 50 people calling and applying for one room or one basement apartment.”
Instead, people just started calling Tanner if they had a room to rent.
“They knew I always had people,” she said.
But now even these calls have stopped.
“It’s just tapped out,” she said.
There are Yukon businesses that can’t recruit employees because there is no housing, said Rick Karp, president of the Whitehorse Chamber of Commerce.
“And 2012 is going to be a significantly difficult year,” he said.
Karp wants to see more development in Whitehorse.
“If you look at a map of Whitehorse, 65 per cent of it is green space,” said Karp. “The average across the country is eight per cent.
“Ironically, we seem to be having difficulties finding land to develop.”
Whistle Bend is a start, said Karp.
But it’s not enough.
“We can’t move quickly enough on places like Long Lake,” he said.
People are afraid large developments will deflate the housing market, said Karp. “But that’s not going to happen.”
A recent mining sector report predicts the industry will spend more than $5 billion in capital expenditures in the territory by 2018.
“There are going to be thousands of jobs,” he said. But there’s no housing.
Last week, Yukon Housing’s budget dropped by $9 million.
And this week, the Yukon government said it’s planning to tweak its Financial Administration Act, giving it greater control over public property. It’s a move in preparation for another tent city this summer.
Tent city residents were evicted in November by White Pass and Yukon Route, which owns some of the property next to the territorial government building where the tent city was set up.
At the time, there was talk of putting some of the homeless in the Alexander Street Residence, since the seniors living there had moved to a new building at Waterfront Place.
Last summer, the government announced the Alexander Street Residence would be used to house 15 to 20 Yukoners with cognitive disabilities, such as fetal alcohol syndrome.
In July, Social Services spokesperson Pat Living said new residents will move in within “weeks, not months.”
Nine months later, the residence remains empty.
Tanner would like to see Whitehorse create a housing co-ordinator position, like ones in Yellowknife, N.W.T. and Juneau, Alaska.
As affordable housing co-ordinator in Juneau, Scott Ciambor provides guidance to the city on housing issues.
So far, this has involved working on everything from homelessness and mental health issues to land allocation and rent-to-own properties.
Ciambor also co-ordinates meetings between upwards of 30 local organizations involved in Juneau’s homelessness and housing initiative, including police, hospital staff, city officials, state employees, realtors, developers, doctors, school board members, mental-health workers, lawyers, church groups and local non-profits.
The City of Yellowknife has a full-time homelessness co-ordinator.
Over the past seven years, Dayle Hernblad has overseen the construction of a youth shelter, a 32-unit transition home for men, a day shelter and the continued maintenance of a 44-bed shelter, while a new 22-unit supported-living complex for women is in the works.
This gives Yellowknife - population 18,700 - more than 90 shelter beds.
Whitehorse - population 26,400 - has 14.
“Last year we had almost 4,000 people come through the Beez Kneez,” said Tanner.
One young man had moved north for work and was washing dishes at a local hotel, but couldn’t find a place to live, she said.
“He was working five hours a day, at $10 an hour. But it cost $30 a night here so he was spending three-fifths of his salary on accommodation.
“Is that what we consider affordable?”
Tanner ended up driving the young man to the Alaska Highway after a few weeks.
“He started hitching back south,” she said.
“If Whitehorse is going to grow and start bringing in workers, then it’s got to find more housing, or we’re going to miss out on individuals who are making contributions to our community and our economy.”
Contact Genesee Keevil at
.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)
18 Comments
Some people have had the comment that rental prices in the Yukon haven’t gone up as much as should be expected. That is a valid argument, but I do want to mention that even though prices go up according to inflation, that doesn’t mean that all people can afford those prices. The problem as I see it is that our government is building for those people who have the funds available to pay the ridiculous rents. If you can afford $1,000 or more a month for a one bedroom basement suite then fine. The problem is the poor people who are looking for a simple place to stay with a minimum wage job that can’t afford these prices. Also, we don’t have accommodation for the minimum wage earner. We need these places for the poor people to have a quality of life and to be able to start someplace and then maybe be able to grow within the system and eventually be able to afford the $1,000 or more per month.
According to a recent article in either this paper or the star, median rent in 1992 in Whitehorse was $610 and that this year it is $775. If rents had kept up with inflation alone, median rent would have hit $775 in 2001! In 2012, it should be $925 just to be equal to 1992 rental rates. Please check my math and tell me if I am wrong but rents are significantly lower in real dollar terms than they were 20 years ago. In 1992 I paid $450 for a small bedroom in a town house shared with four other renters. We had one bathroom. I was a student at the time, and paid my own way. I did not find this onerous nor did I complain about it. Get real, there are a lot of people jumping on the band wagon because they would rather pay less rent and they see it as a popular issue. The indigent people who cannot get housing need a homeless shelter, not hotel rooms. So build them a homeless shelter and lets bloody move on past this issue.
Welcome to life…reap what you sow. And by that I mean no one should be expected to coddle the entitled.
Housing is it an investment or is it a home? This is our dilemma , the market is based on YG wages and not private wage sector. Look at the old retrofitted buildings and check out the markups on these old structures. Greed seems to be what is the problem in the housing.
We are in such a hurry to build until we have no land left. Sad when we have places for people to live in cities already developed and we have to keep searching for “adventure” and depleting the last frontier the animals have left.
We should leave this alone, people are like a disease that keeps spreading until we infect everything in our path. Very selfish very sad .
We are still floundering around on the homelessness issue, and that is perplexing for me this far into the crisis. As Genesee has pointed out in yet another thoughtful article, businesses are having a hard time recruiting talent, new citizens are considering sleeping in their trucks, the government is tweaking laws to give it more power to regulate (prevent?move?) Tent City II and local hostel owners are stepping up as volunteers to help house people while the government does ... what exactly? Have there been any announcements on solutions to ease the housing shortage?
Meanwhile, anonymous bootstrappers simply thump their chests and decry “socialism” without offering any solutions. (C’mon people, step out of the shadows, put your names to your posts and let’s have a real discussion.)
Personally, giving a closer examination to the approaches seen in Juneau and Yellowknife seems like a good start. Yet ... nothing.
As I said, perplexing.
North of 60: Unless I’m mistaken about what Poppa Oscar means, perhaps you should take some of your own medicine and “stop being rude”.
Your comment was that new-comers to the Yukon are industrious and don’t expect free housing. Is anyone asking for free housing? If my comment or interpretation of your position is not accurate then you should read your own comment and understand that deliberately or not, it’s pretty easy to interpret it that way…in no small part due to the tone of your message.
My take on it is we should not provide free housing as you put it, but could do a lot better job of providing affordable housing. COW and YG should be working together on this and and quick look at some of the expenditures that both have on an annual basis tells me that with some responsible decisions about how they spend taxpayers dollars that we could make some progress on this issue.
Why doesn’t the government just give house to people who need them for free? I mean, this seems to be where we are going.
My problem is that one coordinator leads to a team of coordinators, salaries and expenses for travel to housing conferences in Europe and soon the poor tax payer is picking up a hefty tab for all of this nonsense.
People need to take more responsibility for their own lives and stop expecting everything to come from government.
We have a government that had a new leader for the election. He promised things during the election and then turned around after the election and said exactly the opposite. (RE: The Peel)From the people I have talked too, the Yukon Government won the election on the idea that the “same-old-same-old,” was over and things would change. What has actually happened is the “same-old-same-old is still the same-old-same-old” That is why so many of the voters are so upset with this government. The Old boys have to do something or they will no longer be in power.
flyingfur wrote: North of 60 ... I don’t recall any of them taking your “the hell with them…let them starve” attitude. So democracy is working in the Yukon…just not to your liking.
+++++++++++++++++
Stop being rude and attributing your words to my statement. You don’t know my attitude. Try to state your own views clearly and concisely and refrain from trying to interpret what you think others said.
Poppa Oscar.
North of 60 wrote: “We live in a democracy; those people who want free or ‘affordable’ housing for the homeless can run for office on that platform and form a government if they get enough votes.”
Yep we live in a democracy. Seems to me that during the last election that the issue of homelessness came up across the board and all of the parties and candidates had a position on this issue. They were all somewhat different, but I don’t recall any of them taking your “the hell with them…let them starve” attitude. So democracy is working in the Yukon…just not to your liking.
Why would the Yukon Government build housing?
You voted them in, they have four more years, there is no urgency on their part. They are very comfortable.
At best, they will make some promises before the next election in 2016.
This is the perfect storm for another tent city.
yes for all the years i lived up there
yes those buiding have been empty
as randy collins noted, the yukon Government needs too wake up
build more houses or open more land…
In the past when employers couldn’t fill positions because workers couldn’t find housing, then the employers bought ‘company’ houses for their employees.
Until that happens, one can assume that the ‘housing shortage’ is highly overstated.
Those of us who have lived through many Yukon ‘boom and bust’ cycles know that the anticipated economic growth is very optimistic.
Why don’t those people who seem to think that free or ‘affordable’ housing is a ‘human right’ invite the homeless to come live with them?
Perhaps they think someone else should pay to support their beliefs?
Why should those of us who have worked hard to afford a roof over our heads have to support the socialist beliefs of a few with our hard earned tax dollars?
We live in a democracy; those people who want free or ‘affordable’ housing for the homeless can run for office on that platform and form a government if they get enough votes.
The immigrant workers who come here don’t seem to have a problem finding ‘affordable’ housing with their minimum wage jobs. Of course they’re hard working, responsible, and industrious, and don’t believe that the world owes them free housing.
If you think there isn’t enough ‘affordable’ housing then create it yourself, it’s not the government’s responsibility.
Affordable accommodation is not $1000.00/ month. We need to start “screaming” at our government (since they don’t seem to be listening)to put their money where their promises are. I don’t blame the landlords. After all if you can
get $1000.00 or more a month why not? We have buildings that have remained vacant for years (True Value in the Money Mart mall, The Old Canadian Tire store building, The Dairy Queen store)and even some that only are open during the summer (The Klondike Hotel) These could be re-furbished for next year until we can get new properties on the market. Phone, e-mail, Fax your MLA and get them off their Asses and get something done.
but isn’t this what the Yukon Party Government promised? unbridled growth and prosperity?....perhaps Whitehorse should again re-consider its slogan from the “wilderness city” to…“no-room with a view” or “Whitehorse, just like Fort Mac….but with less”....or “just wait until it gets to high season”
so many possibilities….well, I guess Yukoners are getting what they voted for
thats why i moved from whitehorse no housing
could not find rent for 3 people everyone wants too much money for some of
older homes to rent or the new ones… sure there jobs ..no housing..
Add a comment